• Home
  • About
  • Webcasts
  • ‘Enforcement 40’ for 2020
  • Enforcement Hall of Fame
  • Contact
Securities Docket
Ankura 480x60
  • Class Actions
  • Criminal
  • Global
  • People
  • SD Insider
  • SEC
  • Video
  • Subscribe by email
  • Subscribe
Browse: Home / 2008 / December / 10 / Class Actions Challenging JPMorgan Buyout of Bear Stearns Dismissed

Class Actions Challenging JPMorgan Buyout of Bear Stearns Dismissed

By Securities Docket on December 10, 2008, 10:34 pm

Last week, New York State Supreme Court Justice Herman Cahn dismissed the shareholder class actions challenging Bear Stearns’ buyout by JPMorgan Chase & Co.  The court found that Bear Stearns pursued the deal to prevent a “potentially cataclysmic” bankruptcy.

The lawsuits claimed that JPMorgan’s offer to purchase Bear Stearns was “unfair and inadequate,” and that Bear Stearns’ directors breached their fiduciary duties by failing to get the highest possible price. The court concluded that Bear Stearns directors’ approval of the merger didn’t subject them to liability, and granted the bank’s request for summary judgment, because the decisions were “shielded” by the business judgment rule. The court stated that Bear Stearns’ directors acted “expeditiously” to consider the company’s “limited options,” and that “the court should not, and will not, second guess their decisions.”

Robert Giuffra, a litigation partner at New York-based Sullivan & Cromwell told Bloomberg that

“Justice Cahn’s decision reflects that we are living through a period of extreme economic uncertainty…. “Given the financial tsunami that has washed over the economy, it’s hard for plaintiffs’ lawyers to argue that boards of directors have engaged in bad conduct when they’re making the best of a bad situation.”

“The worse the crisis has gotten, the harder it’s become for plaintiffs’ lawyers to successfully challenge corporate boards and executives,” Giuffra said.

Read the Bloomberg article

Blog Widget by LinkWithin

Posted in Class Actions | Tagged Features, M&A

« Previous Next »

‘Enforcement 40’ for 2020

Securities-Docket_Medium-Rectangle_CaseStudyArrow

Our Sponsors

Securities-Docket_260x125_14Sec Ankura 260x125

Join Us On LinkedIn

Join the Securities Litigation and Enforcement Group on LinkedIn

Archives

Copyright © 2021 Securities Docket.

Powered by WordPress and Hybrid.