Letter on Insider Trading from a Confused Wall Streeter — The Insider

To Whom It May Concern:

I am a conscientious professional investment adviser.  For years I have carefully followed legislation, judicial decisions, and news reports regarding the law of insider trading.  I make every effort to stay abreast of the latest developments so that I can fulfill my fiduciary obligation to act in the best interest of my clients and optimize their returns while, at the same time, avoiding any violation of the law against trading on inside information.  The latest decisions by the United States Supreme Court and the highest federal court that covers the area that includes Wall Street have left me paralyzed with uncertainty.  I increasingly am afraid that diligent review, analysis, and investigation on behalf of my clients will land me before the SEC or worse yet a defendant in a criminal case.  The law of insider trading has never been defined by Congress and increasingly I have become aware that federal judges cannot agree on what it is.  In particular, when determining whether a violation has occurred, courts have been battling over whether when information is shared by an insider, he or she must receive a personal benefit and what constitutes such a benefit.  Can someone help me out?!

via Letter on Insider Trading from a Confused Wall Streeter — The Insider