• Home
  • About
  • ‘Enforcement 40’ for 2020
  • Webcasts
  • Enforcement Hall of Fame
  • Contact
Securities Docket
FTI 480x60
  • Class Actions
  • Criminal
  • Global
  • People
  • SD Insider
  • SEC
  • Video
  • Subscribe by email
  • Subscribe
Browse: Home / 2022 / June / 17 / What’s “Controversial” About ESG? A Theory of Compelled Commercial Speech under the First Amendment

What’s “Controversial” About ESG? A Theory of Compelled Commercial Speech under the First Amendment

By Securities Docket on June 17, 2022, 11:34 am

The SEC’s proposed climate disclosure rules create an opportunity to reflect on the limits that the First Amendment places upon securities regulation. As regular readers of this blog know, the SEC has proposed rules to make companies disclose their “climate risks” along with their greenhouse gas (“GHG”) emissions and certain climate-related financial metrics. Unlike existing rules, which require disclosure of climate-related matters when they have a material effect on business operations, the proposed rules largely dispense with the concept of materiality and, where they do not disregard it altogether, significantly alter its meaning. These rules thus raise the question of whether there is any limit on the SEC’s ability to impose them and, in particular, whether there is any First Amendment constraint on the SEC’s authority to mandate disclosures.

My paper, What’s “Controversial” About ESG? A Theory of Compelled Commercial Speech under the First Amendment, analyzes these questions. It argues that there is indeed a First Amendment limit to SEC action and that the proposed climate rules exceed those limits.

Source: What’s “Controversial” About ESG? A Theory of Compelled Commercial Speech under the First Amendment

Blog Widget by LinkWithin

Posted in SEC, Top | Tagged ESG

« Previous Next »

Subscribe

‘Enforcement 40’ for 2020

Securities-Docket_Medium-Rectangle_CaseStudyArrow

Our Sponsors

Securities-Docket_260x125_14Sec Ankura 260x125

Join Us On LinkedIn

Join the Securities Litigation and Enforcement Group on LinkedIn

Archives

Copyright © 2022 Securities Docket.

Powered by WordPress and Hybrid.